Whether you are giving your space a new makeover or you are moving to any new place, a water heater or a geyser is one of the important home appliances. In winter, taking a bath without hot water is a freezing experience.To avoid the bone-chilling experience in winter, we make use of a geyser, but which one to use in your bathroom? A gas geyser vs electric geyser.
Figuring out which one is better is challenging as they both function differently, and both have their advantages and disadvantages.
In this post, you will get complete information on how a gas geyser is different from an electric geyser, and that will assist you in making an informed decision. But before we delve into a detailed comparison of both types of geysers, it’s important to know about both geysers in detail.
About Gas Geyser
In a gas geyser, liquid petroleum gas is used for heating water, and there is a consistent water flow. They could be more powerful and be faster to recover. If you have a very big family, then a gas geyser makes the best choice. They are of two types.
Instant gas geyser: Generally, most of the gas geysers are instant, which means there will be no storage tanks. You can turn the geyser on whenever you require hot water.
Storage gas geyser: This is the best option for those having large families, as this geyser has a storage tank for storing hot water. So, you are required to heat the water once, and then it can be used for a long period.
Working of Gas Geyser
Whenever you open the tap associated with the gas geyser, there will be an ignition of flame, and a click sound indicates that. In the heat exchanger, there will be heat pipes which are covered with metal fins. When you initiate the flame, these fins start getting heated up and then heat the pipes. Water running through these pipes also becomes hot. The whole system is instant as the moment you turn on the flame and the flame starts, hot water will start pouring from your tap.
Benefits of Gas Geyser
- Gas geyser facilitates full control of the heating level and heating rate
- They can operate on both pipeline gas and gas cylinders
- Best for big-size families
- East for maintaining and repairing
- As they don’t need power for running, they can run anywhere and anytime.
Drawback of Gas Geysers
- They have a short lifespan
- It is not very safe as there is a chance of gas leakage
List of top 10 Gas Geyser in India
| Sr. no. | Name of the product | Product Capacity | Product type |
| 1 | V-Guard Safeflo Prime 6Lit LPG Gas Geyser | 6l | LPG |
| 2 | ACTIVA Aqua Gold Pure Copper Tank 6 ltr Instant Gas LPG Water Heater | 6 L | (LPG) |
| 3 | Surya Stainless Steel Instant Gas Geyser | 6.5l | Liquified Petroleum Gas (LPG |
| 4 | BLOWHOT Gas Geyser 6 Litres | 6 L | Water heater (Gas) |
| 5 | Hindware Eveto 6L ISI Gas Water Heater | 6 L | Gas water heater |
| 6 | Bajaj Majesty Duetto Gas 6 LTR Vertical Water Heater | 6 L | LPG Gas Water Heater |
| 7 | Bajaj Shakti Neo 25L Various Safety Systemsr | 25 L | Gas Water Heater |
| 8 | Crompton Gracee | 5 L | Water Heater (Gas) |
| 9 | AO Smith HAS-X1-015 Storage 15 Litre Horizontal Water Heater | 15 L | Storage Gas Geyser |
| 10 | V-Guard 6 L Safeflo PRIME Gas Heater | 6 L | LPG |
About Electric Geyser
The maximum population mostly prefers electric geysers because they are user-friendly and straightforward. While technological advancements have resulted in automatic electric heaters being adopted in most households, the main working principle is the same. Heat is mainly generated through copper heating elements through electricity. This enhances the temperature of the water. Electric geysers are best for small families, and there are many models of geysers available.
Types of Electric Geysers
Instant geysers: Like the name, they offer hot water directly, which means you can turn it on whenever you want, but you cannot store hot water.
Storage geysers: Storage geysers are big, and they work in the same way as the instant geyser. The only difference is they can store water based on the size of your geyser.
Working of Electric Geyser
As soon as you turn the geyser on, the electric current will get converted to heat energy. The water will then pass through the rods, absorbing the heat energy and thus becoming hot. The thermostat present in the geyser will keep the temperature below the set limit. The thermostat should work perfectly, or else your skin might get burned.
Benefits
- It is highly convenient as it gives you hot water just with a flip of an electric switch.
- Easy for handling and installation
- Because of electricity, water is heated very fast
- They are safe as no fuel is involved
- The source of energy is cheap
- Longer lifespan and highly durable
Drawbacks
- Because of the mode of working of electric geysers, they require a constant source of power for running. When there is no power, your geyser will not work.
- Expensive for purchase, operation, and maintenance.
List of top 10 Electric Geysers in India
| Sl.no | Product Name | Capacity of the product | Type |
| 1 | A.O. Smith 15L Storage Water Geyser (HSE-VAS-X-015, White) | 15l | Storage |
| 2 | Bajaj 3L Instant Water Geyser (Flora, White) | 3 | Instant |
| 3 | V-Guard 15L Storage Water Geyser (Victo, White) Share | 15 | Storage |
| 4 | Racold 25L Storage Water Geyser (Eterno Pro SP, White & Purple) | 25 | Storage |
| 5 | Racold 15L Storage Water Geyser (Eterno Pro SP, White) | 15 | Storage |
| 6 | AO Smith HSE-SES-15 15-Litre 2000-Watt Vertical Water Heater (Blue & White | 15 | Instant |
| 7 | Havells Instanio 3-Litre Instant Geyser (White/Blue), Wall Mount | 3 | Instant |
| 8 | Usha Aquagenie 10 LTR 2000-Watt 5 Star Storage Water Heater (Ivory Wine) | 10 | Storage |
| 9 | Bajaj Flora Instant 3 Litre Vertical Water Heater, 3KW, White wall mounting | 3 | Instant |
| 10 | Crompton Bliss 3-L Instant Water Heater with Advanced 4 Level Safety (White) | 3 | Instant |
Gas Geyser vs Electric Geyser: A Comprehensive Comparison
Now that we have a good knowledge of what gas geyser is and what electric geysers along with their mode of working and benefits and drawbacks, we should now have a thorough comparison to know which one is better.
| Sl.no | Factors | Gas Geyser | Electric geyser |
| 1 | Safety | Not very safe as LPG use is inflammable | Safe to use |
| 2 | Effectiveness | Less effective | More effective |
| 3 | Price | Affordable | Pricey |
| 4 | Time for heating water | Requires time for heating water | Instantly produces heat water |
| 5 | Space required | Requires more space | Fits in even in small washroom |
| 6 | Durability | Lasts for 6 years | Lasts over 8 year |
| 7 | Environmental impact | Bad effect because of carbon monoxide | No environmental effect |
| 8 | Ease of installation | Easy installation | Easy to install |
Now let’s see about Gas Geyser vs Electric Geyser in details.
- Operation process: Electric water heaters are easily accessible when compared with gas heaters because all you have to do is switch on the power supply to get hot water. But with a gas geyser, you have to turn on the gas and also control it properly, or else it might lead to an accident.
- Infrastructure: When you install for the first time, both gas geysers and electric geysers are easy to install. If you have to change the mode, then you have to do some infrastructure changes. For instance, changing from an electric geyser to a gas geyser needs gas lines, the drilling of new holes, and the installation of pipes. Similarly, when switching to an electric geyser, you have to make the required electric installations.
- Effectiveness: Electric water heaters are more effective when compared with gas heaters as you will get hot water more quickly. The manufacturers of electric water heaters also use advanced technology to enhance the corrosion resistance of internal container tanks. This is the reason the heat is retained inside for more hours, thereby making the geysers more effective.
- Cost of operation: Gas heaters require more time to heat water, but the cost of operation is less when compared with electric geysers. Electricity is more expensive when compared with natural gas or LPG. Electric geysers will consume 3 – 4 units of electricity every day. But the initial expense of a gas geyser is more than that of an electric geyser.
- Cost of maintenance: The gas heater’s maintenance cost is higher when compared with the electric heaters. In gas geysers, there are no heating elements when compared with electric water heaters. They operate on burners that need servicing for the prevention of blockages. The gas pipes also get blocked easily when not maintained properly.
- Environmental problems: Gas heaters mainly work on exhausted resources such as LPG or natural gas. Other than that, gas heaters also release considerable amounts of greenhouse gas into the environment. So, they are not environmentally friendly. However, electric geysers are eco-friendly as they are powered by renewable sources of energy.
- Safety: Both types of geysers have their own set of risks. Electric heaters possess the risk of causing electric shocks, especially when proper earthing is not done. In the same way, excess heat can enhance the pressure in the geyser, which leads to blasts. Gas geysers are also risky as the natural gas is flammable. Moreover, leakage can also cause hazardous incidents.
So, which is better, a Gas Geyser or an electric geyser?
Both gas and electric geysers are good options. If you are installing for the first time and you are on a tight budget, then an electric geyser is good; however, if you want to save in the long run, then go for a Gas Geyser. The best water heater for your house totally depends on your own choices and requirements. Ask yourself all the questions before making an informed decision about which geyser you should buy.
We all have varied lifestyles with varied incomes and cultures. After going through a gas geyser vs. electric geyser comparison, select the perfect geyser for your home or any other place. Both choices are good if you are taking all the required precautions.
Gas Geyser vs Electric Geyser Comparison Faqs
Which is a better option, a gas geyser or an electric geyser?
Both options have their own set of benefits and drawbacks. Which one is better for you depends purely on your requirements and preferences. From a safety point of view, electric geysers are safer. Case any damaged electric geyser might lead to a short circuit, but in the case of gas geysers, it leads to an explosion.
Which geyser is best for home?
An electric geyser is the best option for a home as they are easy to manage and maintain. They can be installed without thinking of ventilation. They also last long and are power-effective.
Are geysers harmful?
Yes, if all necessary precautions are not taken, then both types of geysers are harmful. Any damage in electric geysers can lead to short circuits, and in gas geysers, it can lead to explosions.
